Expunging your criminal record can be a life-changing step, giving you a clean slate and new opportunities in work, life, and housing. For Indiana residents, the state’s Second Chance Laws provide a path to do just that. But what happens if a misstep in the process delays or, worse, denies your petition for expungement? Filing mistakes are more common than you might think, and they can jeopardize your case.
This guide will walk you through Indiana’s expungement process and the common mistakes you must avoid to ensure success. You’ll also learn why working closely with an experienced expungement lawyer can increase your chances of having your record sealed or wiped clean.

What Is Criminal Record Expungement and Why Does it Matter?
Expungement is the legal process that allows individuals to seal or remove past criminal records, effectively providing a fresh start. For many, this means better job prospects, access to housing, and the removal of social stigma tied to past mistakes.
Indiana has specific laws, known as Indiana’s Second Chance Laws, designed to give you the opportunity to leave your past behind. However, navigating this process can be overwhelming, riddled with complex requirements, paperwork, and strict deadlines.
That’s why attention to detail and understanding the process are essential.
Key Eligibility Requirements and Deadlines for Indiana Expungement
Before you file your expungement application, it’s crucial to understand Indiana’s expungement criteria. These typically include the following:
Waiting Periods
Indiana requires waiting periods depending on the type of criminal offense. For example:
- Arrests without conviction or dismissed charges require at least one year.
- Misdemeanors require five years after conviction.
- Felonies generally require eight years post-conviction.
Eligibility
You must meet specific criteria, such as completing all terms of sentencing, including fines, restitution, and probation. Additionally, certain severe crimes, such as sex offenses and violent crimes, cannot be expunged.
One-Time Opportunity
Indiana allows a person to petition for expungement only once in their lifetime. The stakes are high—any mistakes could cost you your only chance at a clean record.
Failing to meet these requirements can result in an automatic denial of your application, underscoring the importance of accuracy and legal guidance.
6 Common Indiana Expungement Mistakes to Avoid
1. Misunderstanding Eligibility Criteria
One of the biggest pitfalls is misunderstanding whether you qualify. Indiana’s expungement criteria are strict, with nuanced rules based on the type of offense. For example:
- If your conviction involves violent crimes or public office misconduct, you may not be eligible for expungement.
- Some individuals fail to account for waiting periods, unknowingly submitting their applications prematurely.
How to avoid this mistake: Check Indiana’s laws thoroughly and consult an expungement lawyer in Indianapolis to confirm your eligibility.
2. Failing to Disclose All Prior Arrests
Expungement in Indiana requires you to disclose all prior arrests and convictions—even those you may think are irrelevant or too minor to mention. Omitting any arrest raises red flags and could lead to outright rejection of your petition.
How to avoid this mistake: Request your complete criminal history to ensure no arrests or charges go undisclosed. This includes minor infractions and dismissed cases.
3. Not Obtaining Certified Records
You must include certified copies of your criminal records with your petition for expungement. These records should come from the court where you were charged, not just printed from online databases.
Unfortunately, many applicants try to save time by submitting unofficial documents, not realizing this will lead to rejection.
How to avoid this mistake: Contact the relevant clerk’s office to obtain certified copies of all necessary records. Start early, as this can take time.
4. Incorrectly Filling Out the Expungement Petition
Filing an incomplete or incorrect petition for expungement is another common error. Mistakes—such as misspelling names, wrong case numbers, or mismatched dates—can derail your case. Small errors may be perceived as carelessness by the court, which could impact their willingness to grant your request.
How to avoid this mistake: Double-check every form field and review your petition multiple times, ideally with the help of a legal professional.
5. Missing Deadlines for Filing Paperwork
Indiana’s expungement process is time-sensitive, with strict deadlines for filing once you initiate the process. Missing these deadlines can lead to costly delays and, in some cases, disqualification.
How to avoid this mistake: Create a timeline and calendar reminders, and work with a legal team to ensure you meet all required deadlines.
6. Neglecting to Follow Up with the Court
Submitting your application is not the end of the road. Many people assume that the court will take care of everything once the petition is submitted—a mistake that can prolong the process or even result in missed hearings.
How to avoid this mistake: Follow up regularly to verify the status of your application. Attend court hearings if required and ensure all remaining steps are completed.
Key Takeaways
Expungement is a powerful tool to unlock new opportunities, but it’s a complex process fraught with potential mistakes. Each error risks prolonging your case or forfeiting your one chance for a clean slate under Indiana’s Second Chance Laws.
The good news? You don’t have to go through it alone. Whether you’re unsure about your eligibility, struggling with deadlines, or concerned about making mistakes, an experienced expungement lawyer can help you avoid costly errors.
We specialize in guiding Indiana residents through the expungement process step by step. Contact us today at 317-636-7514 for expert guidance and ensure your petition is filed perfectly the first time. Take the first step toward a brighter future. Our Indiana criminal expungement services start as low as $850. Call us today or schedule a free consultation.
Related Posts:
Mistakes to Avoid When Pursuing Criminal Record Expungement in Indiana
How to Fix a Mistakes on Your Criminal Record
From Stigma to Success: Navigating Indiana’s Record Clearing Process